Long Island, NY Metro >
1742 Sag Harbor Tpke,
Sign in to Write a Tip
Very good veggie burger! Wellness Foundation menu items too.
I love their falafel burger! Joe & Liza ice cream is also served here, which is delicious!
Cool Beans..... Open again. Best Burgers, best service, can't wait until the Lobster rolls get back. Ummmmmm!!!!
Great burgers in the perfect place for it. Everything is customizable to make it taste how you like, or just ask someone working to make you their favorite. If you got lobster, you missed the point.
I'm a local and this is one of my favorites! Good beer on tap, local wines and amazing burgers....could you ask for more?
The music is great tonite...
The food is great, but if you like your burgers rare, skip it. For some reason they just don't know what a rare burger looks like.
The lobster rolls are all lobster, no filler!
Skip the burger, try the homemade ice cream! Dulche de Leche is fantastic. A decent burger, but nothing to go out of your way for. Similar style to NYC's Goodburger or Burger Joint.
5 Napkin Burger watch out best burger and lobster roll in town.
See more tips for Bay Burger
Sign in with Facebook
Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!
Get the Citysearch Mobile app so you can spend less time searching for great places, and more time enjoying them.
Get it Now